Most flips go wrong at the offer, not at the hammer. A price that felt fine turns out to leave no profit once every cost is counted. This guide shows the backward method GenesisOS uses, so you know your top price before you ever call the seller.

Two rules that come before the math

Over 30 years in real estate, two rules have held up every time:

  1. You make your money when you buy, not when you sell. By the time you list the house, the profit is already decided by the price you paid and the costs you took on.
  2. Treat your profit as a non-negotiable expense line. Do not hope there will be a profit at the end. Put it in the budget at the start, like the rehab or the closing costs, and refuse to pay a price that does not pay it.

GenesisOS is built on these two rules. Its math puts your required profit in the list of costs, then tells you the most you can pay.

Start from the sale price and work backward

Many people start with the asking price and hope the rest works out. GenesisOS does the opposite. It starts with what the house will sell for after repairs, called the ARV (after-repair value). Then it subtracts everything else.

The formula is simple:

Maximum price = ARV minus rehab, minus selling and closing costs, minus holding costs, minus financing costs, minus the profit you require.

What is left is the most you can pay. Anything above that number eats your profit.

Know the costs you are subtracting

  • Rehab: the repair bill. See our guide on estimating a rehab.
  • Selling and closing: agent fees and closing costs when you sell. The default is 3% of ARV.
  • Holding: taxes, insurance, and utilities while you own it. The default is 1% of ARV.
  • Financing: loan interest and fees. The default is 5% of ARV.

These defaults are a starting point. Change them to match your market and your lender.

Worked example: a $250,000 ARV and a $40,000 rehab

This is an example with round numbers, not a real deal. The costs below use the default percentages.

ARV$250,000
Rehab$40,000
Selling and closing (3%)$7,500
Holding (1%)$2,500
Financing (5%)$12,500
Required profit$25,000
Maximum price (profit only)$162,500

$250,000 minus $40,000, $7,500, $2,500, $12,500, and $25,000 leaves $162,500.

Check the price against every minimum

Profit alone is not enough. GenesisOS scores each deal on four checks, using your company minimums. The defaults are:

  • Profit of at least $25,000.
  • ROI (return on investment: profit divided by total money in the deal) of at least 18%.
  • Margin (profit divided by ARV) of at least 15%.
  • Rehab/ARV (rehab divided by ARV) of no more than 30%. Lower is better.

Try the $162,500 price against them:

CheckResultMinimumPass?
Profit$25,000$25,000Yes
ROI11.1%18%No
Margin10.0%15%No
Rehab/ARV16.0%30% maxYes

The profit looks fine, but ROI and margin fail. The best price must satisfy all the minimums at once. Lowering the price to $149,400 gives $38,100 profit, 18.0% ROI, and 15.2% margin. Every check passes. That is your real top price, and it is $13,100 below the profit-only number.

Use the 70% rule only as a quick screen

The classic 70% rule says: pay no more than 70% of ARV, minus the rehab. Here that is $175,000 minus $40,000, or $135,000.

Be honest about what this is. It is a rough filter for sorting leads fast. It does not look at your actual holding, financing, or selling costs. At $135,000, the itemized math shows $52,500 of profit, which is far more than you needed. On a different house, the rule could just as easily be too generous. The two methods answer different questions, so itemize before you make a real offer.

Ask "what if" before you commit

Estimates are never exact. The Deal Analyzer tests one bad surprise at a time, keeping every other cost at the dollar amount you entered. Here is the $149,400 deal with two surprises:

ScenarioMax Purchase PriceProfit
Base case$149,400$38,100
ARV 5% lower$136,900$25,600
Rehab 15% higher$143,400$32,100

Read the Max Purchase Price column as "what I would have had to pay to keep my profit." If the ARV comes in 5% low, you would have needed to pay $12,500 less. If the rehab runs 15% over, you would have needed to pay $6,000 less. Since you can never go back and pay less after you have bought, this is the table to study before you make the offer. Profit still clears $25,000 in both cases, but the ARV scenario leaves almost no room. If that worries you, offer less.

Common mistakes

  • Leaving out holding, financing, or selling costs.
  • Trusting an optimistic ARV. Check your comps.
  • Using a rehab number from memory instead of an itemized estimate.
  • Checking only profit and ignoring ROI and margin.
  • Treating the 70% rule as the answer instead of a screen.

How GenesisOS does it

In the Deal Analyzer, pick the Rehab & Flip strategy and enter the ARV, purchase price, and rehab. The app fills in financing, holding, and selling costs from your Settings, and you can override them. It shows the pass or fail checks for profit, ROI, margin, and Rehab/ARV. A Deal Score then averages the checks: Strong is 85 or higher, Moderate is 60 to 84, and Weak is under 60.

The Find Best Purchase Price window finds the price that meets your minimums. The (i) bubbles show each formula with the deal's own numbers. The sensitivity table shows the "what if" results next to the Base Case. Your minimums are editable in Settings.

Key takeaways

  • Work backward from ARV: subtract every cost and your required profit.
  • The best price must pass profit, ROI, margin, and Rehab/ARV together.
  • Use the 70% rule as a quick screen only, then itemize.
  • Test a lower ARV and a higher rehab before you make the offer.