After-repair value, or ARV, is what the home should sell for once the work is done. Comps are how you estimate it. Every number in your analysis depends on getting this one right.
What comps are
Comps, short for comparable sales, are homes similar to yours that recently sold. Their sale prices show what buyers in that area will actually pay. They are a record of what happened, not a guess.
Aim for three to five good comps. One sale can be a fluke. Several sales that agree tell a real story.
Choosing and adjusting comps
How to choose comps
Good comps look as much like your finished house as possible. Check each one against this list.
- Distance: Close by, ideally the same neighborhood. Avoid crossing major roads or school boundaries.
- Size: Similar square footage, bedrooms, and bathrooms.
- Age: Built in a similar period.
- Condition: Compare your finished house to renovated comps, not to homes in poor shape.
- Recency: Recent sales are best. Older sales may not reflect today's market.
- Sold, not listed: A listing is an asking price. Only a closed sale shows what a buyer paid.
- Same type: Compare single-family to single-family, not to condos or multi-family.
Adjusting for differences
No two homes match exactly. When a comp differs from your house, adjust its price to make it equal.
- If the comp is better than yours in some way, subtract from its price.
- If the comp is worse, add to its price.
For example, if a comp has an extra bathroom that your house will not have, subtract what that bathroom is worth. Keep adjustments small and reasonable. If you need big adjustments, that comp is probably a poor choice. A local agent or appraiser can help you with the amounts.
Find a range, not one number
After adjusting, you will have several values. Look at the low, middle, and high. That range is more honest than a single figure. Then choose a number inside the range.
Be conservative
You make your money when you buy, not when you sell, and the ARV is what you are betting on when you buy. A number you cannot defend with sold homes is a hope, not a number.
Ask yourself what could go wrong: the market could soften, the sale could take longer, or buyers could expect more finish work than you planned. A flip loses money when the ARV is set too high, and you only find out after you have bought. Lean toward the lower and middle end of your range. Do not use the best sale on the street just because it looks good. If your numbers only work at the highest value, the deal is probably thin.
A simple comps worksheet
Use a table like this for each deal. The numbers below are an example only.
| Item | Comp 1 | Comp 2 | Comp 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Address | Example A | Example B | Example C |
| Sold date | 2 months ago | 4 months ago | 5 months ago |
| Distance | 0.2 mi | 0.4 mi | 0.6 mi |
| Sale price | $305,000 | $295,000 | $300,000 |
| Adjustments | -$5,000 | +$5,000 | $0 |
| Adjusted price | $300,000 | $300,000 | $300,000 |
Worked example: what a 5% miss costs
This example uses round numbers and the GenesisOS default costs: financing 5%, holding 1%, and selling 3% of ARV, with a $25,000 minimum profit. The rehab is $40,000.
| Item | ARV $300,000 | ARV $285,000 (5% lower) |
|---|---|---|
| Financing | $15,000 | $14,250 |
| Holding | $3,000 | $2,850 |
| Selling | $9,000 | $8,550 |
| Maximum purchase price | $208,000 | $194,350 |
A 5% error in ARV lowers the maximum price by $13,650. If you paid $208,000 and the home really sold for $285,000, your profit would be $11,350, not $25,000.
Here the selling, holding, and financing costs were recalculated at the lower ARV, the way real life works. The app's "ARV 5% lower" what-if scenario is a little different: it keeps every cost at the dollar amount you entered and changes only the ARV, so you see the effect of that one change by itself.
Common mistakes
- Using listing prices instead of sold prices.
- Picking only the highest comps.
- Comparing to homes of a different type or size.
- Using old sales in a changing market.
- Making big adjustments to force a comp to fit.
- Not saving the comps you used.
How GenesisOS does it
In the Deal Analyzer, ARV is the starting point for every strategy. For a Rehab and Flip, the app works backward from ARV: it subtracts selling, holding, and financing costs, your rehab, and your required profit, and what is left is the maximum purchase price. Financing, holding, and selling costs are a percent of ARV by default. The Wholesale and BRRRR strategies also start from ARV, and BRRRR uses it for the refinance loan amount.
The sensitivity table includes an ARV 5% lower scenario so you can see this risk against your Base Case. Save your comps in Documents with the deal.
Key takeaways
- Use sold homes that are close, recent, similar, and the same type.
- Adjust for differences in plain, small steps.
- Work with a range and lean conservative.
- An ARV error ripples through every cost and your profit.
- Save your comps with the deal.



