A rental deal can look good on one number and fail on another. A checklist keeps you honest. This one is grouped by area and tied to the same checks the GenesisOS Deal Analyzer runs on a BRRRR deal.

How to use this checklist

Go top to bottom. If you cannot answer an item, that is a gap to close before you make an offer. Where a check says "default," that is the starting minimum in GenesisOS. Your company can change each one in Settings.

1. The numbers

  • Do I have an ARV (after-repair value) backed by real sold homes, not a hope?
  • Is Rehab / ARV at or below 30%? Lower is better.
  • Is Monthly Cash Flow at or above $1,000 after the loan payment?
  • Is Cash-on-Cash at or above 15%?
  • Is Cap Rate (NOI divided by purchase price) at or above 10%?
  • Did I include other costs (holding and financing) in Total Investment?
  • Did I run the "what if" with a higher interest rate and lower rent?

Example, using round numbers: ARV $200,000, purchase $130,000, rehab $30,000, rent $3,000 a month. That gives Total Investment of $162,000, Monthly Cash Flow of $1,012, Cash-on-Cash of 101.2%, and Cap Rate of 18.1%. All four checks pass. Drop the rent to $1,900 and cash flow falls to $110, cash-on-cash to 11.0%, and cap rate to 9.8%. It fails three.

2. The property

  • Have I walked every room, the roof, and the exterior?
  • Is my rehab estimate built from line items, with a contingency on top? The GenesisOS default contingency is 10%.
  • Do I know which big systems are near the end of their life: roof, HVAC, plumbing, electrical?
  • Have I checked for permits, code issues, and anything that might delay the work?
  • Do I have a contractor who has given a written bid?

3. Tenants and market

  • Do I have rents from similar homes nearby, not just online listings?
  • Is the home the kind tenants in this area want (bedrooms, parking, location)?
  • How long do similar homes sit empty? Is the 5% vacancy default fair here?
  • Do I have a screening process, a lease, and a plan for late rent?
  • Will I manage the house myself or hire a manager? Is the 8% management default right?

4. Financing

  • How will I pay for the purchase and rehab?
  • Will the refinance lender use a loan-to-value of 75% of ARV, or something else?
  • What interest rate and term did the lender quote, and what if the rate rises a point?
  • Do I know about any waiting period before I can refinance?
  • What happens if the appraisal comes in lower than my ARV?

5. Reserves

  • Do I have cash set aside for repairs, vacancy, and surprises?
  • Can I cover the mortgage and costs for several months with no rent?
  • Did I budget for maintenance (default 5% of rent) and taxes and insurance (default 1% of ARV each per year)?
  • If the cash left in the deal is more than I expected, can I still handle it?

Putting it together

Before you make an offer, write one line for each of the five areas: what you know, what you are guessing, and what you still need to find out. Guesses are fine early. They are not fine at closing. Turn each guess into a fact by calling a lender, walking the house with a contractor, or checking local rents. Then enter the numbers in the Deal Analyzer and read the checks. If one check fails, ask which input is weakest and go verify that one first.

Common mistakes

  • Falling in love with one strong number and ignoring the others.
  • Using the best-case rent.
  • Counting on the refinance to return cash before the appraisal is in.
  • Having no reserves.
  • Skipping the "what if" test.

How GenesisOS does it

The Deal Analyzer BRRRR strategy scores every deal against your minimums for monthly cash flow, cash-on-cash, cap rate, and Rehab / ARV. It shows a Deal Score (Strong 85+, Moderate 60 to 84, Weak under 60) and a sensitivity table that tests ARV 5% lower, rehab 15% higher, interest rate one point higher, and rent $150 lower. The Estimator builds a rehab estimate from the Cost Library, adds Contingency, and feeds the total into the deal's Rehab input. Once you buy, add the house to Managed Properties. Taxes and legal questions belong with your accountant and attorney.

Key takeaways

  • Check all four numbers: cash flow, cash-on-cash, cap rate, and Rehab / ARV.
  • Verify ARV and rent with real local data.
  • Test the deal with a higher rate and lower rent.
  • Keep cash reserves for repairs and empty months.
  • Ask your accountant and attorney about tax and legal questions.